ComparisonsMac6 min read
Petal vs VoiceInk: two open-source Mac dictation apps
Petal vs VoiceInk: compare MIT vs GPL v3, a free signed build vs a paid license, macOS requirements, paste methods, and cleanup options on Mac.
Published by Optimal Apps, the maker of Petal.
On this page
Petal vs VoiceInk is a comparison of two open-source Mac dictation apps that both run speech models locally. The main differences: VoiceInk is under GPL v3 and sells a one-time license for its signed app ($25 to $49 at the time of writing), while Petal is under the MIT license and its signed app is free. VoiceInk runs on macOS 15 or later. Petal needs macOS 26.2 or later on Apple silicon. Both have per-app behavior and AI cleanup. They differ in paste methods and in the local cleanup model.
Disclosure: Optimal Apps publishes Petal and this site. VoiceInk facts come from tryvoiceink.com, its docs, and its GitHub repository at the time of writing.
Petal vs VoiceInk: quick comparison table
| VoiceInk | Petal for Mac | |
|---|---|---|
| License | GPL v3 | MIT |
| Signed app price | $25 (1 Mac), $39 (2), $49 (3), one time | Free |
| Build from source | Free | Free |
| Free trial | Yes | Not needed |
| macOS | 15 or later; Apple silicon recommended for local models | 26.2 or later; Apple silicon only |
| Local speech | Whisper and Parakeet models, Apple Speech on macOS 26 | Parakeet, Whisper, Qwen3 ASR, Voxtral, Nemotron, Apple Speech |
| Cloud speech | Optional | No; speech always local |
| Local cleanup | VoiceInk Refine, Ollama, Local CLI | Petal W1, Apple Intelligence, Ollama or LM Studio |
| Cloud cleanup | OpenAI, Anthropic, Mistral, Gemini, Groq, Cerebras, custom | OpenAI, Anthropic, OpenRouter, custom server |
| Per-app behavior | Modes with app and website triggers | Router with app and website routes |
| Paste methods | Default, AppleScript; Direct Typing in newer builds | Command-V with clipboard restore |
| Clipboard restore | Keep Clipboard Content, Restore Delay (default 2 s) | Restore Clipboard, 700 ms |
License: MIT vs GPL v3
Both apps publish their source code, so you can check how they handle audio and keys.
- VoiceInk (GPL v3). If you change the code and distribute your version, it must stay under GPL v3, with source. The developer sells licenses for the signed build. The license gives automatic updates and support, and funds the work.
- Petal (MIT). You can reuse the code in other projects, open or closed, if you keep the license notice. The signed build from GitHub Releases is free and updates through Sparkle.
For a user who only wants to dictate, the license matters less than the price of the signed build.
Price and the signed build
VoiceInk has a free trial and one-time licenses: Solo $25 for 1 Mac, Personal $39 for 2 Macs, and Extended $49 for 3 Macs, with lifetime updates and a 14-day money-back guarantee. Third-party pages say that these are sale prices. You can also build VoiceInk from source for free, but then you sign it yourself, and you do not get automatic updates.
A self-built app has a different code signature. VoiceInk's GitHub issue #530 shows the result: macOS links Accessibility to the signature, so the permission shows "on" but does not work after a rebuild. The fix is tccutil reset Accessibility com.prakashjoshipax.VoiceInk, a relaunch, and a new grant.
Petal ships one Developer ID signed build for free, so most users never build it.
macOS requirement
VoiceInk runs on macOS 15 or later. Local models work best on Apple silicon, and VoiceInk recommends cloud transcription on Intel Macs. Apple Speech in VoiceInk needs macOS 26.
Petal needs macOS 26.2 or later and builds only for Apple silicon (arm64). If you are on macOS 15, or on an Intel Mac, VoiceInk is the option of the two that runs.
Paste methods
Paste failures are the top complaint for all Mac dictation apps. Both apps paste through the clipboard and need Accessibility.
VoiceInk
In Settings > Pasting, VoiceInk has:
- Paste Method: Default or AppleScript. VoiceInk suggests AppleScript for custom keyboard layouts.
- Keep Clipboard Content: restores your old clipboard after the paste.
- Restore Delay: default 2 seconds, from 250 ms to 5 seconds. Raise it if the old clipboard pastes.
- Auto Send: press Return after the paste.
VoiceInk issue #1000 describes paste failures in some Chromium web fields. A newer Direct Typing method sends Unicode keystrokes. For full steps, read VoiceInk not pasting.
Petal
Petal waits until you release the modifier keys, then sends Command-V. It restores your old clipboard after 700 ms, because Electron apps such as VS Code read the clipboard late. In Settings > Recording, turn off Restore Clipboard if you want the transcript to stay on the clipboard. In Settings > General:
- Paste Last Transcription sets a shortcut to paste the last result again.
- Send Now: while you record, press Control-X then Control-S to stop, paste, and press Return.
Petal has no AppleScript or typing mode.
Cleanup options
VoiceInk
AI Enhancement in VoiceInk works with OpenAI, Anthropic, Mistral, Gemini, Groq, Cerebras, Ollama, a Local CLI, and custom OpenAI-compatible providers. VoiceInk also lists a built-in local model, VoiceInk Refine, which does not take custom prompts or context. You set the provider, model, and prompt in each Mode.
Petal
In Settings > Intelligence, Petal has:
- Petal W1: an on-device model fine-tuned from Qwen3.5-2B. It removes fillers, repeats, and false starts, and keeps your voice. The Petal README reports its scores on 120 held-out dictations.
- Apple Intelligence: rewrites with your instructions on supported Macs.
- Cloud Model: OpenAI, Anthropic, or OpenRouter with your own key, or a custom server such as Ollama or LM Studio. Presets include Clean Up, Email, Notes, Professional, AI Prompt, and Assistant. Variables such as
{{app}}and{{window}}add context. - Off: paste as said.
Keys stay in the macOS keychain.
Per-app behavior
VoiceInk Modes (the older name was Power Mode) apply their own transcription, enhancement, and output settings. Triggers can be apps, websites, spoken words, or a shortcut.
The Petal Router (Settings > Router) gives each app or website a route with its own intelligence, style (clean up or paste as said), and instructions. It also lets you pick one speech model for dictation and another for audio files. Read per-app dictation cleanup on Mac.
The two designs are close. VoiceInk has more trigger types. Petal has a separate speech model for files.
How to try Petal next to VoiceInk
- Quit VoiceInk, so the shortcuts do not conflict.
- Download Petal from GitHub Releases and move it to Applications.
- Allow the microphone.
- Open System Settings > Privacy & Security > Accessibility and turn on Petal.
- In Settings > Models, download Parakeet 110M, or the same Whisper model that you use in VoiceInk.
- Press Option-Space in a text field, speak, and stop.
- In Settings > Intelligence, try Petal W1, then compare with your VoiceInk enhancement.
Which one to choose
Choose VoiceInk if you are on macOS 15 or an Intel Mac, you want cloud speech as an option, or you need AppleScript paste or typing for a special keyboard layout.
Choose Petal if you are on Apple silicon with macOS 26.2 or later and want a free signed build, an MIT license, and the Petal W1 on-device cleanup model.
Related guides
Get Petal for Mac.
Questions
Are Petal and VoiceInk both open source?
Yes. VoiceInk's source is under GPL v3, and Petal is under the MIT license. VoiceInk sells a license for the signed app with updates; building from source is free. Petal's signed app is free.
What does VoiceInk cost?
At the time of writing, VoiceInk lists one-time prices of $25 for 1 Mac, $39 for 2 Macs, and $49 for 3 Macs, with a free trial and a 14-day money-back guarantee. Petal for Mac is free.
Which macOS versions do they need?
VoiceInk needs macOS 15 or later and recommends Apple silicon for local models. Petal needs macOS 26.2 or later on Apple silicon.
Why does VoiceInk paste my old clipboard?
VoiceInk restores the old clipboard after a delay. If the app reads the clipboard late, raise Restore Delay in Settings > Pasting. The default is 2 seconds. Petal restores after 700 ms, and you can turn Restore Clipboard off.
What does MIT vs GPL mean for me?
For normal use, nothing changes. For developers, GPL v3 requires that changed versions that you distribute stay under GPL v3 with source. MIT lets you reuse the code with few conditions, as long as you keep the license notice.