ComparisonsMac5 min read
Petal vs MacWhisper: dictation and file transcription
Petal vs MacWhisper: compare live dictation, dropped-file transcription, models, price (free vs EUR 64 Pro), and the App Store edition difference.
Published by Optimal Apps, the maker of Petal.
On this page
Petal vs MacWhisper is a question of which job comes first. MacWhisper is a file transcription app first: it has subtitle export, speaker recognition, batch jobs, media URLs, and meeting recording, with a free version and a Pro license for EUR 64. Petal for Mac is a dictation app first: you press a shortcut, speak, and Petal cleans up and pastes the text into the front app. Petal also transcribes dropped audio files, and it is free and open source. Both run models on your Mac.
Disclosure: Optimal Apps publishes Petal and this site. MacWhisper facts come from macwhisper.com and its documentation at the time of writing.
Petal vs MacWhisper: quick comparison table
| MacWhisper | Petal for Mac | |
|---|---|---|
| Main job | File transcription | Live dictation |
| Price | Free; Pro EUR 64 one time | Free |
| License | Closed source | MIT, open source |
| Live dictation | Yes, in the macwhisper.com edition only | Yes |
| File transcription | Yes, with batch jobs | Yes, one file at a time |
| Subtitle export (.srt, .vtt) | Yes | No |
| Speaker recognition | Yes | No |
| Media URLs (YouTube) | Yes | No |
| Meeting recording | Automatic for Zoom, Teams, and others | No |
| Watched folders and integrations | Yes | No |
| Local models | Whisper, Parakeet, and others | Parakeet, Whisper, Qwen3 ASR, Voxtral, Nemotron, Apple Speech |
| Cleanup | AI services with your own keys, Ollama, LM Studio | Petal W1 on device, Apple Intelligence, your own cloud key |
| Per-app behavior | Not compared | Router per app or website |
Editions: why this matters for dictation
MacWhisper comes in two editions:
- MacWhisper from macwhisper.com, with a Pro license sold through Gumroad.
- Whisper Transcription on the Mac App Store, with its own in-app purchases.
A Gumroad license does not unlock the App Store edition. MacWhisper's documentation says that system-wide dictation is only in the macwhisper.com edition, because of rules for Mac App Store apps. If you bought the App Store edition for dictation, that is the reason that you do not see it. Read MacWhisper dictation not working.
Petal has one edition. You download it from GitHub Releases, and it updates through Sparkle.
Live dictation
MacWhisper
In the macwhisper.com edition, you press a hotkey, speak, and the text appears in the active text field. MacWhisper checks for a text field first. Some apps do not expose their text fields correctly. For those, MacWhisper's docs say to turn on Settings > Advanced > Allow dictation everywhere.
Petal
Petal is built around dictation:
- Shortcut. Option-Space by default. Tap to start and stop, or hold and release. A double-tap mode is also available.
- Capsule. A small floating capsule shows that Petal listens and works. With Show Live Transcript on, your words appear above it with models that transcribe live.
- Cleanup. In Settings > Intelligence, select Petal W1 (on device), Apple Intelligence, Cloud Model (your own key), or Off.
- Router. In Settings > Router, each app or website can have its own cleanup. Read per-app dictation cleanup on Mac.
- Paste. Petal pastes into the front app and restores your old clipboard after 700 ms. The Paste Last Transcription shortcut pastes the last result again.
- Send Now. While you record, press Control-X then Control-S to stop, paste, and press Return.
File transcription
MacWhisper
File transcription is where MacWhisper is strongest. It supports batch transcription, 100 languages, subtitle export as .srt and .vtt, text and document export, speaker recognition, translation, YouTube and media URLs, an inline video player, and watched folders that send results to tools such as Notion or Obsidian. For podcasts, videos, and interviews, these features matter.
Petal
Petal transcribes one audio file at a time:
- Drop an audio file on the Petal menu bar icon, or choose Transcribe Audio File… in the menu.
- Petal transcribes it with the selected model.
- Petal copies the text to the clipboard and adds it to the history.
Petal accepts AAC, AIFF, CAF, FLAC, M4A, MP3, MP4, and WAV files. In Settings > Router > Speech Models, you can choose a fast model for dictation and a slower, more accurate model for files. Petal has no subtitle export and no speaker labels. Read transcribe an audio file on Mac.
Model sets
Both apps run Whisper and Parakeet models locally.
MacWhisper lists Whisper and Parakeet and other on-device models, plus many cloud services with your own keys, such as OpenAI, Anthropic, Google Gemini, Groq, Deepgram, and ElevenLabs.
Petal lists these models in Settings > Models:
| Model | Size | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Parakeet 110M | about 455 MB | Fast English, recommended |
| Parakeet 0.6B V3 | about 485 MB | 25 European languages |
| Whisper Large V3 Turbo | about 1.1 GB | 99 languages |
| Qwen3 ASR 1.7B | about 2.5 GB | 30 languages |
| Voxtral Realtime 4B | about 3.2 GB | Streaming, 13 languages |
| Parakeet Unified 0.6B, Nemotron Unified 0.6B | about 625 MB, 1.2 GB | Live text as you speak |
| Apple Speech | No download | Apple's on-device framework |
Petal does not send audio to a cloud speech service. Cloud keys in Petal are only for the text cleanup step.
Price
MacWhisper is free, with a Pro license for EUR 64 one time with lifetime updates. The site does not mark which features are free and which are Pro, so check the current page before you buy. The App Store edition has its own prices.
Petal for Mac is free. There is no Pro tier on Mac.
Test the same audio file in both
Use the same file to compare accuracy and speed on your Mac.
- Record a two-minute M4A with Voice Memos. Use names and terms from your own work.
- In MacWhisper, open the file and transcribe it with Whisper Large V3 Turbo, or the nearest model.
- In Petal, download Whisper Large V3 Turbo in Settings > Models.
- In Settings > Router > Speech Models, set Audio Files to Whisper Large V3 Turbo.
- Drop the same file on the Petal menu bar icon.
- Paste the Petal result next to the MacWhisper result.
- Compare names, punctuation, and the time to finish.
- Repeat with Parakeet in both apps.
With the same model, the results are often close. The difference is in the features around the model.
Which one to choose
Choose MacWhisper if you transcribe podcasts, videos, interviews, or meetings, and you need subtitles, speaker labels, batch jobs, or integrations.
Choose Petal if you mostly dictate into apps, you want on-device cleanup and per-app routes for free, and you transcribe a file only now and then. Petal needs Apple silicon and macOS 26.2 or later.
Many people use both: MacWhisper for files, and a dictation app for typing by voice.
Related guides
Get Petal for Mac.
Questions
Which is better for file transcription, Petal or MacWhisper?
MacWhisper. It has subtitle export, speaker recognition, batch transcription, media URLs, and watched folders. Petal transcribes one audio file at a time and copies the text to the clipboard and the history.
Which is better for live dictation?
Petal is built for dictation first: a shortcut, a capsule, cleanup with Petal W1, per-app routes, and paste into the front app. MacWhisper also has system-wide dictation, but only in the edition from macwhisper.com.
Does the App Store version of MacWhisper have dictation?
No. MacWhisper's documentation says that dictation is only in the edition sold on macwhisper.com, because of Mac App Store rules. The App Store edition is named Whisper Transcription and has its own purchases.
How much does MacWhisper cost?
MacWhisper has a free version and a Pro license for EUR 64 one time, with lifetime updates, at the time of writing. Petal for Mac is free and open source.